But thanks to social media and the crew's unquenchable thirst for cold, hard cash, police were able to track down and nab the thieves.
“What got 'em was greed. If they would have just stuck to the plan but not showed the money off publicly, we might still be trying to figure out who they are right now,” Portland Police Det. Eric McDaniel said.
3 months after the gang of 4 men stole a pair of diamonds worth $150,000 from the David Marguilis’ jewelry store in Portland, Oregon, on Dec. 15, 2010, police got their first big break when a tip helped identify the man who ran out of the store with the diamonds as Victor Lupis.
During an interrogation, Lupis confessed to the crime and told police that there was an entire cast of characters involved in the theft and began naming the other thieves, police said.
According to Lupis, Michael Young, who called himself the risk reducer, was the ringleader, the mastermind behind their whole operation.
A federal judge sentenced Remor to 10 years in prison for his involvement in the jewelry thefts
During the jewelry thefts, police said Young sat outside orchestrating the entire event while communicating through a disposable phone.
“He had the guys convinced that he pre-planned everything to a point where the risks were reduced and there, the likelihood of them getting caught was zero,” McDaniel said.
When Lupis told Young he left his fingerprints on the front door of the Portland jewelry store, Young returned to the store during all the confusion and wiped them off, Lupis told investigators.
According to detectives, Young, an ex-convict, implied that he was part of a crime family and threatened retaliation to those who dared to cross him. He was also a master manipulator, persuading new recruits with the promise of money, Lupis told police.
“They usually go after a female, and an older female if they can because they just believe that they’re just the most vulnerable person to steal from,” McDaniel said. “Once they kind of built a relationship with an employee at the jewelry store, they would start looking for the higher-end diamonds.”Without Lupis, Jack Cannon often played the role of the runner, McDaniel said.
Police were unable to find anyone who knew and liked Cannon because “he’s a manipulator and only cares about himself," McDaniel said.
“Matter of fact, we learned on social media that there’s a website dedicated to Jack Cannon about all the girls that hate him,” McDaniel said.
Cannon would dress the part of a high-end jewelry customer and was able to make people trust him.
“He was dressed up in a suit and tie. He drew attention to himself in that the one that was able to identify him thought he was attractive,” Tampa Police Department Det. Melinda Rewis, who was the lead investigator of the jewel ring’s robbery at King Jewelers in Tampa, Florida, told “20/20.”
Rewis said Cannon also altered his look by dyeing his hair blond.
Though police were able to identify Cannon by a fingerprint he left at the Tampa jewelry store, Cannon, who was charged in the robbery, didn’t show up for future court appearances and continued his robbery pattern across the country, Rewis said.
The group’s social media photos of their travel helped detectives track their movements, eventually helping lead to their arrests.“What’s memorable about Jack Cannon is his demeanor and the way he talks to people, that’s what people most remember about him,” Las Vegas Det. Aaron Lee, who investigated Cannon’s involvement in a robbery at the Jewelers of Las Vegas store, told “20/20.” “This was a classic con man. He did everything right to make people feel comfortable when he went in the store.”
“As the case progressed and we learned more about where the suspects had committed diamond thefts, we were able to look on the social media sites and see some correlating photos from where the crimes had occurred,” Hughes said.
Cannon is now serving a 30-year sentence after being indicted on charges of robbery with a weapon and conspiracy.
The second-in-command to Young’s risk reducer role was the "hero stopper" Ernest Remor, Lupis told police.
“The person that stops the hero is gonna have some spray on him or something to try to incapacitate the good citizen trying to stop the thief,” McDaniel said.
Remor and Young, both in their 30's, had tried and failed to steal diamonds before and spent some time in prison for their efforts.
After each theft, Remor flew to Jewelers' Row in Philadelphia with the stolen diamonds that they could sell for cash at the Three Gold Brothers store.
A federal judge sentenced Remor to 10 years in prison for his involvement in the jewelry thefts.
According to Lupis, the team’s getaway driver was Trey Adams.
“He can never bring himself to do the actual theft of the diamonds, but his big role was to steal cars, usually minivans, and be the getaway driver,” McDaniel said.
Adams drove a white Dodge minivan he stolen when the thieves robbed the Portland jewelry store, Lupis told police.
“You steal a car, and it was never registered to you. There’s nothing on paper showing you put money down for it, and that way you can just leave it,” McDaniel said. “So there was a risk there, but I think it was a smart one.”